Wrong Big Picture, Dangerous Fine Print

National Review, Vol. LXI No. 14 | Published on

By James C. Capretta and Tevi Tory

Print Friendly


There are only two problems with the emerging Democratic plan to reform health care in the United States: the big picture, and the fine print.

From a macro perspective, the bills now moving through House and Senate committees call for a combination of employer and individual mandates to force more, though not all, Americans to purchase federally set levels of insurance coverage. Some Americans — mainly those without full-time jobs — would be eligible for a new entitlement to discounted premiums. The federal government would try to tell doctors and hospitals what constitutes appropriate medical practice.

The bills would pay for their insurance subsidies with significant new taxes, mainly on work and entrepreneurship, as well as some benefit cuts in Medicare. The bills would also create a new government-run insurance plan that would be available to many working-age people and would likely constitute the first step toward a single-payer system.

That’s the broad vision of Obamacare, which is bad enough because of what it will mean for the quality of American medical care over time. There are only two ways to allocate health-care resources: with a market or with government regulation. The Democratic vision firmly rejects consumer choice and a decentralized marketplace in favor of near-total federal-government control of health care. In time, that will mean cost control in the form of waiting lists, less innovation, and reduced quality.

But the fine print is likely to be just as alarming to Americans as this big picture is. The bills are chock-a-block with government intrusion into medical practice, limits on personal freedom, costly requirements that will stifle the private economy, massive and expensive government bureaucracy, taxes, fees, and fines.

It’s apparent that Democratic leaders in Congress and the Obama administration would like to keep these details out of the public spotlight, which is why there is an odd disconnect between the timeline for the legislation’s consideration in Congress and the timeline for its implementation.

President Obama has of late been spending much of his energy arguing that it is absolutely urgent that both chambers of Congress pass a bill this summer so that a final bill will get to his desk by October. Why? Why, because “the time is now.” And the status quo is unacceptable. And we’ve never been this close before.

Never mind that in the bills as now written, nothing would actually happen for more than three years. Indeed, no uninsured American would get health insurance under the Democratic bills until 2013 at the earliest. In fact, the CBO has estimated that the number of uninsured Americans will increase in 2011 and 2012, before the bills’ major provisions go into effect. And of course 2013 is safely after the next presidential election, just in case anyone’s keeping track.

This is about political momentum. The administration and Democratic leaders in Congress understand that the more people learn about what these bills would actually do to American health care, the less the public will like them. Consider just this small sampling of the bills’ details:

Severe limits on the purchase of private insurance. The House Democratic bill would make it illegal for Americans to buy health insurance from a company outside of the new structure. It’s the government-approved system or nothing.

Government-controlled market access. In the bill approved by Democrats on the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee, states would have the authority to limit the number of insurance offerings provided to consumers in “exchanges,” which are the government-run agencies that oversee consumer enrollment in insurance plans. Qualified insurers seeking to offer coverage to “exchange” participants may or may not get to do so. It would be up to government bureaucrats, who could deny market entry to an insurer for apparently any reason. It’s entirely predictable that this broad authority will be abused to benefit politically connected providers — at the expense of consumers.

The “commissioner.” House Democrats would hand over vast powers to a new “Health Choices Commissioner,” the head of the new bureaucracy charged with regulating basically all health insurance offered in America. The commissioner would become the choke point for all major health-care-policy decisions, such as what constitutes qualified insurance or employer compliance with the federal mandate to offer coverage. States would even be required to enter into agreements with the commissioner regarding the operation of their Medicaid programs. Vast power and little accountability: It’s a recipe for unresponsive bureaucracy, arbitrary rulemaking, meddling, and even more paperwork.

Penalizing work. In both the House and the Senate HELP bills, full-time work is heavily penalized. For the most part, the unemployed and part-timers are entitled to subsidized insurance. But full-time workers get no such subsidy. Their employers must offer them coverage or face severe penalties, and the workers have no choice but to take it, because otherwise they would face severe penalties themselves. This burden will be especially hard on low- to middle-income Americans who don’t sign up for job-based insurance today because they can’t afford it.

Funding abortion and abortion providers. Both the Senate HELP and House Democratic bills fail to exclude abortion from the services that constitute “qualified” insurance — which means, as a practical matter, abortion would be a required “covered benefit.” Thus, federal taxpayers would be forced to pay for abortions, and everyone would be forbidden to get insurance that does not cover abortion, even if he is spending only his own money.

Raising premiums with taxes on health benefits. The House bill creates something called a Health Care Comparative Effectiveness Research Trust Fund (CERTF), which would be funded by fees on insurance providers. But insurers won’t pay these fees themselves; they will be passed on to consumers in the form of higher premiums. President Obama pilloried Senator McCain for proposing “for the first time in history . . . taxing people’s health-care benefits,” yet that is essentially what House Democrats are looking to do in their bill.

Deep Medicare cuts for beneficiaries living in low-cost areas. House Democrats are determined to force seniors out of the private-insurance program of Medicare, called Medicare Advantage (MA). According to the Congressional Budget Office, their bill is likely to work as planned: Some 5 million MA enrollees would get pushed back into the traditional government-run program, with its lower benefits and higher cost-sharing. This would happen because the House bill bases MA payment rates on the estimated regional cost of covering someone in the traditional program; those living in lower-cost areas would see their payment rates drop, making the traditional program look more attractive.

This approach worsens the unfair regional disparities that exist today. For instance, this year, the MA payment rate in Portland is only $819 per month, while Miami’s is $1,238 per month. The House bill would widen this gap by cutting Portland’s MA payments by 26 percent, since Portland is a low-cost region with a culture of judicious use of health services. Meanwhile, Miami, which is rife with Medicare fraud and abuse, would get only a 2 percent cut in its MA payment rate. Medicare beneficiaries in Salt Lake City, Sacramento, Albuquerque, and other low-cost cities would get hit almost as hard as Portland’s beneficiaries. This runs precisely counter to the notion, popularized by Atul Gawande in The New Yorker and heartily embraced by the Obama administration, that we should try to replicate, or at least reward, areas that provide mor
e efficient health care.

Undermining entitlement reform. Section 1901 of the House bill would repeal a trigger intended to alert Congress and the broader public to the financing problems in the Medicare program. Under current law, the HHS secretary must propose Medicare program adjustments to eliminate projected funding shortfalls when the Medicare trustees forecast excessive program reliance on subsidies from the Treasury. Repealing this provision is one more indication that Democrats are not serious about addressing the explosion of entitlement spending, which will push U.S. fiscal policy off a cliff in relatively short order.

More government-run health care. So much attention has been focused on President Obama’s push for a new government-run insurance plan that many people do not realize that the Democrats are also seeking the largest expansion of Medicaid in the program’s history. Medicaid spending is already on track, along with Medicare, to push federal finances to the brink. Between 2009 and 2035, the CBO expects combined spending for these two programs to increase from 5.3 to 10 percent of GDP. But that’s apparently not enough: The House bill would add 11 million more enrollees to Medicaid, bringing total enrollment to about 71 million and adding more than $80 billion in new spending to the budget in 2019 — on top of the $426 billion that the program will already cost under current law.

These bills are a massive overreach by the Democrats, who see this year as a once-in-a-generation opportunity to have something like a New Deal or Great Society moment. Most Democrats believe strongly in total governmental control of health care, and they are determined to try to achieve it now, regardless of the fiscal and political consequences. So they press on, even as every day brings new revelations of the incoherence, hubris, and excesses of their plan.

It might work; the legislation might pass. Then again, it might not, as a restless public is becoming increasingly alarmed at what is emerging from Washington. A government takeover of health care seems not to be what the public wants — meaning that the Democrats may find themselves advocating bad policy that is unpopular to boot.

– Mr. Capretta, a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center and a health-policy consultant, was an associate director at the White House Office of Management and Budget from 2001 to 2004. Mr. Troy, a visiting senior fellow at the Hudson Institute and a health-policy consultant, was deputy secretary of health and human services from 2007 to 2009.

Trackbacks

  1. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More Infos here: eppc.org/publications/wrong-big-picture-dangerous-fine-print/ [...]…

  2. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/wrong-big-picture-dangerous-fine-print/ [...]…

  3. ntdqcvvtl says:

    ntdqcvvtl…

    Wrong Big Picture, Dangerous Fine Print – Ethics & Public Policy Center…

  4. Thank you…

    Any ideas of what I can write about? What would you be interested in reading? And how can I get people to see it?….

  5. Trackback says:

    I have some question…

    If you like reading a blog, what kind of interesting things that make you like that blog? Give me your favorite blog links too…..

  6. Trackback says:

    Maybe……

    How do you create your own blogger header for your blogspot?…

  7. Trackback says:

    Good info…

    I am starting a business selling various baby things that I make. And I want to start a website to be able to sell them on. Can anyone tell me the steps that I would need to go through to do this? And what is the cost?. Thanks…..

  8. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Find More Informations here: eppc.org/publications/wrong-big-picture-dangerous-fine-print/ [...]…

  9. Trackback says:

    wow thats great…

    How do I allow contributors to see only their uploads in WordPress?…

  10. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/wrong-big-picture-dangerous-fine-print/ [...]…

  11. Trackback says:

    Like it…

    How can I change to fluid width in the New Blogger Template Designer?…

  12. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Informations on that Topic: eppc.org/publications/wrong-big-picture-dangerous-fine-print/ [...]…

  13. bz13oF8UK8 says:

    The Birch of the Shadow…

    I believe there could become a several duplicates, but an exceedingly useful checklist! I’ve tweeted this. Numerous thanks for sharing!…

  14. XZS7sUKylP says:

    Woman of Alien…

    Great work you have carried out, this web site is basically neat with wonderful details. Time is God’s means of retaining all the things from going on at the same time….

  15. Google says:

    Google…

    Here are a few of the sites we advocate for our visitors….

  16. viagra says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/wrong-big-picture-dangerous-fine-print/ [...]…

  17. paintless dent repair training…

    [...]check below, are some absolutely unrelated internet websites to ours, on the other hand, they’re most trustworthy sources that we use[...]…

  18. paintless dent repair training…

    [...]below you’ll locate the link to some web sites that we feel you need to visit[...]…

  19. porn says:

    porn…

    [...]usually posts some quite exciting stuff like this. If you’re new to this site[...]…

  20. VIRGIN PORN says:

    VIRGIN PORN…

    [...]check below, are some entirely unrelated internet sites to ours, even so, they may be most trustworthy sources that we use[...]…

  21. promo says:

    promo…

    [...]we came across a cool web site that you simply may possibly take pleasure in. Take a appear should you want[...]…

  22. paintless dent removal training…

    [...]we came across a cool web site that you simply could possibly love. Take a search when you want[...]…

  23. childrens toys…

    [...]we like to honor numerous other internet websites around the internet, even if they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Under are some webpages worth checking out[...]…

  24. Trackback says:

    I like your blog…

    Hello, I’m having trouble trying to change the settings for my facebook account. I use firefox, and when I opened the account I clicked on the button saying I wanted firefox to remember my password info. Well, I’ve now changed my mind and want to rem…

  25. ulc ordination…

    [...]Here are several of the sites we advocate for our visitors[...]…

  26. Trackback says:

    Funny…

    How do I save my Firefox bookmarks when getting a new computer?…

  27. http://www.Redwoodbridges.com...

    [...]Every the moment in a even though we select blogs that we read. Listed below would be the latest internet sites that we select [...]…

  28. wedding photographers in Oklahoma…

    [...]please take a look at the web sites we follow, like this one particular, as it represents our picks from the web[...]…

  29. Trackback says:

    Like it…

    Ok so I have looked around a lot on this matter and I keep finding stuff like VNC (or VNSea) that allows you to access the computers on your WiFi network, but all of these require you to install something onto the computer itself. Is there a way to acc…

  30. find facebook password…

    [...]usually posts some extremely intriguing stuff like this. If you are new to this site[...]…

  31. asigurari online…

    [...]Here is a good Weblog You might Find Fascinating that we Encourage You[...]…

  32. Trackback says:

    Maybe……

    How to transfer firefox bookmarks from one laptop to another laptop?…

  33. axbOaeeCEM says:

    The Silent Shard…

    This could almost certainly be pretty valuable for many of the job opportunities I want to you should not only with my weblog but…

  34. email list broker…

    [...]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine some unrelated information, nevertheless actually worth taking a search, whoa did a single study about Mid East has got additional problerms also [...]…

  35. … [Trackback]…

    [...] There you will find 36209 more Infos: eppc.org/publications/wrong-big-picture-dangerous-fine-print/ [...]…

  36. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/wrong-big-picture-dangerous-fine-print/ [...]…

  37. Trackback says:

    Maybe……

    I post them, they get 1 or 2 views, and then no more. I would like my content to do more than just give me a few views… how do I get them on the search engines or something like that? Will no one ever go to my blog just because I don’t post every da…

  38. Trackback says:

    I like your blog…

    I have a diet blog i just started, i have about 3 posts, someone said i should start promoting i now. I thought i should wait until i had at least 10 posts and feedback from a few people in various forums before I promote it so maybe in 2 weeks. What d…

  39. paintless dent removal training…

    [...]very few internet websites that happen to become in depth beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[...]…

  40. pdr-training.net…

    [...]Here is an excellent Blog You may Uncover Fascinating that we Encourage You[...]…

  41. paintless dent repair training…

    [...]usually posts some really intriguing stuff like this. If you’re new to this site[...]…

  42. iphone 5 says:

    iphone 5…

    [...]Sites of interest we’ve a link to[...]…

  43. … [Trackback]…

    [...] There you will find 28666 more Infos: eppc.org/publications/wrong-big-picture-dangerous-fine-print/ [...]…

  44. apartment remodeling…

    [...]Here are a few of the sites we advise for our visitors[...]…

  45. I have some question…

    How do I make firefox show at the top of my start list?…

  46. ways to connect with other bloggers and…

    grow your blog. the quality of your followers is more important than quantity. remember, you’re trying to build up important relationships that can benefit both parties involved. be generous with your retweets and others will be generous with theirs. …

  47. Trackback says:

    Funny…

    I like Facebook, but I hate that their notes section isn’t as appealing as MySpace’s blogs. I’ve recently transferred a blog from MySpace to Facebook using the “share” icon located beneath each blog… However, I do not like the way it appears on …

  48. pdr-training.net/‎…

    [...]one of our visitors recently suggested the following website[...]…

  49. vegas escorts…

    [...]the time to study or pay a visit to the content or web pages we’ve linked to beneath the[...]…

  50. Trackback says:

    Maybe……

    Since the MSM is totally skewed, what blogs/websites have you found that give you information that the MSM ignores?….

  51. very large and there are weekly meetings,…

    or weigh-ins, to keep participants motivated. many companies sponsor weight watchers groups in the workplace with weekly meetings held once a week during the lunch hour so that people with a busy schedule do not have to carve out time to…

  52. Fertility Hypnosis…

    [...]we came across a cool web-site that you may enjoy. Take a search for those who want[...]…

  53. Kosmetik Online Shop – Sonnencreme…

    [...]we like to honor quite a few other net internet sites on the web, even if they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Underneath are some webpages worth checking out[...]…

  54. Sonnencreme – Luxus Sonnencreme…

    [...]although internet sites we backlink to below are considerably not associated to ours, we really feel they may be in fact really worth a go by, so have a look[...]…

  55. Trackback says:

    I like your blog…

    i want to start a website to sell my beaded jewelry but i dont know how to start website so if u have any ideas or frnds that u know please tell me i really nee help or if u have any frnds that like wearing jewelry please tell me to i can do special or…

  56. fair idea of the writers and their…

    writing styles. you can also talk to the writers directly to choose the ones that you think will be able to write for you. in case you do not like the final write up, you can always ask for a rewriting…

  57. paying for some sort of hosting service…

    and must have your own domain in order to install your blog on. you can install your blogging platform from the control panel of your hosting service, usually it is under fantastico. the biggest advantage of self hosted blogs is that…

  58. will take a lot of hard work,…

    but you need to also write many worthwhile blog posts in your topic field. you will have to work hard to get a steady stream of readers, so don’t start unless you’re in it for the long haul.the waiting period between…

  59. Cheap Prescription Medication…

    [...]the time to study or take a look at the content material or web pages we’ve linked to beneath the[...]…

  60. to. examples are the yahoo directory and…

    google directory. monetize your blog with these methods: ads: sign up for an account with google adsense and start placing ad codes in your blog. affiliate marketing: sign up for a clickbank account and find a product to promote. place links…

  61. Trackback says:

    Maybe……

    How do I add Facebook comment box to Blogger, different in each post?…

  62. Emprendedor says:

    Emprendedor…

    [...]The information and facts mentioned within the report are several of the very best available [...]…

  63. butter fruit juices cereal with low fat…

    milk minestrone soup yoghurt with fruits salad with light/low fat dressing chicken breast with whole wheat bread fruits grilled chicken with pasta (whole wheat) steamed vegetablesyou can also combine these snacks to create a complete meal that includes…

  64. and number of featured articles to display.j-post…

    sliderthis plug-in is designed to make your articles and photos look elegant and attractive in j-qurey box. additional features of this plug-in include a powerful back-end where you can actually change the opacity, slider settings, colors, rotating tim…

  65. getting to. the goal is to have…

    your tweet returned on the public timeline for any site-wide searches for your keywords; the people behind those searches, qualified by their keyword intent toward your topical niche, make up your targeted traffic.smoke the hash(tag)hashtags–created b…

  66. pdr training says:

    pdr training…

    [...]please check out the sites we stick to, which includes this a single, as it represents our picks in the web[...]…

  67. your blog or website. it may take…

    a few hours after the ads are placed on your site for the search engines to determine the nature of your content so the ads are relative to it.blogging with adsense can help pay for the fees incurred for internet services…

  68. paintless dent repair training…

    [...]Here are several of the web sites we advocate for our visitors[...]…

  69. Panorama says:

    that you deem important – use images…

    to break up text-heavy blog posts – write shorter paragraphs7) show personality. i really write the way that i talk. i’m not trying to impress anyone. i just want people to get to know the real me, because the real me…

  70. fast. some strategies for building backlinks are…

    from paid traffic sources (like facebook ppc). another effective method for generating targeted, website traffic is article writing.the above tips are great for generating free and paid traffic.are you ready to start generating more blog traffic? austr…

  71. paintless dent repair training…

    [...]we came across a cool internet site that you simply might appreciate. Take a search if you want[...]…

  72. Imc9AElKLy says:

    Third Flower…

    My spouse and that i are already now delighted that Albert could perform his studies as a result of the strategies he had through your web content. It’s now and again perplexing to just constantly be making a gift of techniques which lots of people co…

  73. vietnam flowers…

    [...]Here is a superb Weblog You might Obtain Interesting that we Encourage You[...]…

  74. website says:

    filled with slang terms and phrases. it…

    seems as if instead of teaching them to improve their writing, they have to instead teach them how to write.it is important that english composition courses teach students to improve their writing skills, especially because students need them so desper…

  75. hello kitty says:

    hello kitty…

    [...]The data mentioned inside the write-up are several of the best offered [...]…

  76. JKmjPscMhD says:

    Thorn of Girl…

    Excellent facts is usually identified on this web blog….

  77. nodents.com says:

    your site. if people begin linking to…

    your article or blog post what they are in effect doing is voting that your site, article or blog post relates more to a subject (keyword) that other sites, blog posts etc…how to do a blog post that makes moneyso you…

  78. enjoy the freedom…

    [...]just beneath, are many completely not related web sites to ours, having said that, they are surely really worth going over[...]…

  79. every single day to write and you…

    will become an expert some day. all the best! doing guest blogging is now considered one of the most powerful and most efficient way to drive traffic to your website or blog. it’s as effective as forum and blog commenting and…

  80. Good info…

    I want to start a personal blog.. an online journal. I have no idea which blog website to start it with… anything I should know about having a blog and who to have one with?….

  81. your own blog, go! do it!and if…

    you’re not sure what you need to do to host a domain, then please feel free to contact me and i can help you set up your blog for as little as 10$/mo for me to host it for you.phone: 560-329-0909…

  82. a fashion blog can post a blog…

    article on ‘best way to clean leather boots?’ solicit experience sharing from your blog readers and you will have a regular following that will be happy to recommend your blog, helping you promote it online. for example, everybody loves a bit…

  83. people will seek jobs in the government,…

    which increases job competition.there is one bright side to this realistic portrait: the late-career veteran can be more competitive for overseas work than either early- or mid-career veterans. for one thing, money is not an issue; everyone is getting …

  84. pay you top dollar.selling products is another…

    way to make money with a website. unlike selling products offline, selling goods in the internet opens up more market and target buyers around the world, not just the people within your local area. since you don’t have a physical store,…

  85. show your authority by hosting your own…

    blog. this article will discuss how to go about choosing the right blog host for your needs.your web host is the foundation on which your blog is not only stored online, but experienced by your readers, so it’s of utmost importance…