The Synapse and the Soul

Wall Street Journal | Published on

By Adam Keiper

Print Friendly


Human by Michael S. Gazzaniga
(Ecco, 447 pages, $27.50)

What is it that makes us human — that sets us apart from other animals? What drives us to act altruistically? Why do we gossip and flirt and empathize? How do we judge beauty, and why are we impelled to create works of art?

In Human: The Science Behind What Makes Us Unique, Michael S. Gazzaniga argues that modern neuroscience is on the brink of offering us real answers to these questions — answers more reliable and truthful than those that centuries of philosophy, religious tradition and literature have offered. Thanks to advances in brain research, Mr. Gazzaniga believes, “things have changed.” We can at last set aside vague speculation and get down to facts. We can finally understand love and courtship and the roots of morality. We can put an end to the “long windbag discussions about art.” If we want answers, science has them.

Once we have been armed with the latest scientific findings about how our brains came to be and how they function, how ought we to act? The findings of neuroscience do not immediately penetrate to the most intimate levels of personal experience.

What science tells us is simple and, by now, familiar: Who we are today is the result of eons of evolutionary adaptations serving our basic biological impulses to survive and reproduce. Evolutionary pressures shaped our bodies and minds as well as our social behaviors. There is almost nothing in human social life, Mr. Gazzaniga says, that cannot ultimately be explained by recourse to evolution.

“All those social relationships we now worry about so intensely,” he writes, “are merely byproducts of behavior originally selected to avoid our being eaten by predators.” Our social instincts were formed by “hunting, herding, hiding, and hustling.” Mr. Gazzaniga even takes a stab at explaining the supposed biological origins of religious belief, although that section of his argument is (blessedly) brief. In essence, he claims that religious practices and beliefs satisfy certain “moral modules” — innate affinities for things like hierarchy, purity and coalitions.

Mr. Gazzaniga is at his best when he is describing his own research with brain-damaged and split-brain patients — that is, patients in whom the tissue between the left and right brain hemispheres has been severed. He tells of one woman who, “although she was being examined in my office at New York Hospital, claimed we were in her home in Freeport, Maine.” A lesion on her brain had left her so convinced that she was really at home that she subordinated any conflicting information. When Mr. Gazzaniga asked her why, if she really were in her house, there were elevators outside the door, she responded: “Doctor, do you know how much it cost me to have those put in?”

By demonstrating the organic origins of our most basic sense of our selves, such stories can challenge our understanding of personhood, agency and identity. Unfortunately, Mr. Gazzaniga buries such provocative anecdotes amid the clutter of too-familiar findings from the evolutionary-psychology crowd. How many times must we be told that symmetrical faces, suggesting health, tend to be more attractive?

The whole effort is hindered by Mr. Gazzaniga's quippy writing style (“Are you saying the big brain is for flirting? Does that mean that Frenchmen have the biggest brains?”) and his tendency to plod from one study to the next. Science is, to be sure, a vast collaborative enterprise, but Mr. Gazzaniga's book at times reads like an interminable bibliography or faculty directory. He quotes so often, and at such length, from a few researchers — e.g., social psychologist Jonathan Haidt, primate researcher Richard Wrangham and Palm Pilot inventor Jeff Hawkins — that even a patient reader might be tempted to put down Mr. Gazzaniga's book and pick up theirs.

More important, Mr. Gazzaniga does little to explore the implications of the research he describes. Once we have been armed with the latest scientific findings about how our brains came to be and how they function, how ought we to act? The findings of neuroscience do not immediately penetrate to the most intimate levels of personal experience. If you are scared of heights, it will make you no less afraid to hear that the “actual cause” of your feeling is a catecholamine rush. But neuroscience is increasingly playing a role in marketing, education and the law, and Mr. Gazzaniga offers no insights into whether this growing influence is justified or appropriate.

To the extent that Mr. Gazzaniga provides any guidance about the future, it is that he believes the evolution of our brains isn't over yet. Throughout Human, he describes the brain with the computer lingo that saturates so much neuroscience writing: circuits, programs, wiring and so on. In the last and longest chapter, he takes the analogy further by exploring the “interface” between minds and machines — both the researchers who are trying to simulate the human mind through artificial intelligence and those who have sought to use implants to get information into or out of the brain. “Who needs flesh?” he asks.

Mr. Gazzaniga is far too credulous in this closing chapter, especially regarding the extravagant claims of some robotics researchers. But worse, he doesn't consider what the coming age of mind enhancement and neural implants might mean. He concedes that tweaking human biology could have unintended consequences, just as tinkering with the natural world has sometimes gone awry. But he does not acknowledge that science alone cannot judge where our powers over our world and our selves should be limited.

The basic assumption of Human is that biological science is superior to every other way of thinking about human life. But that assumption leaves us unable to judge when science itself has gone too far. We may, in the end, feel compelled to turn to the very sources of wisdom — philosophy, tradition, faith and even “long windbag discussions” — that Mr. Gazzaniga scorns.

Mr. Keiper is the editor of The New Atlantis and a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center.

Trackbacks

  1. … [Trackback]…

    [...] There you will find 36163 more Infos: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  2. lawyer says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  3. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  4. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  5. UAE says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  6. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  7. sleep apnea says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Find More Informations here: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  8. Souls in the Waves…

    Excellent Morning, I just stopped in to visit your web site and assumed I’d say I loved myself….

  9. penny stocks says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  10. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Informations on that Topic: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  11. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More Infos here: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  12. The Absent Game…

    Between me and my husband we’ve owned much more MP3 players through the years than I can count, together with Sansas, iRivers, iPods (basic & touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few years I’ve settled down to one line of gamers….

  13. … [Trackback]…

    [...] There you will find 94314 more Infos: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  14. try a static sign up form first…

    and give it a month and see how it’s performing. if you’re not pleased with the results try using a pop-up form. many people find these extremely annoying, while some internet marketers report doubling their sign up rates. again you will…

  15. write a good comment, get approved so…

    that others can see your comment. if you created interest,readers will go to your site and that is where you present your products. if you really feel that you have a lot to say about the subject you are reading, don’t…

  16. to a new location. you do that…

    by backing up your wordpress site and restoring it somewhere else.why should you clone your wordpress blog? because it makes for a nice sandbox site where you can test changes, you can get paid to setup your exact blog configuration for…

  17. oven repairs says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More Infos here: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  18. chance to guest-write. then just like in…

    ezinearticles, backlink back to your site. using appropriate heading tags: in many blogs, a lot of people write about important topics in a single post but forget to show the search engine what is important and what is really just another…

  19. funded and maintained by donations. donations are…

    one of the few reasons why nonprofits (npos) need a professional nonprofit website.nonprofit websiteshaving a professional nonprofit website makes it much easier to receive donations. through the website the organization can spread their message and ta…

  20. geldlenen says:

    well.learn to open your mind to new…

    things such as failure and defeat for you to be able to accept that there are things that you need to do perfect your skills.find a writer’s group near you and join them. this group will consist of writers who have…

  21. reader * catchy image that creates curiosity…

    * easy to find bullet points * cite surprising statistics * easily scannable * show personality * link it up * edit and trim your posts * no-brainer call to action1) irresistible title. the best way to find an irresistible title…

  22. a strong following and before you’re making…

    any money from your site. blogging is among the most common tools that entrepreneurs use to promote their business online and the results it provides are nothing less than impressive.in order to reap the rewards of blogging, however, you need to…

  23. company.expand your audience – interesting blog posts…

    have the potential to reach new readers that are interested in your services or products. these readers are unlike the ones that are reading traditional advertisements or even your company’s website. so write content that enables your readers to bette…

  24. your online home business or the same…

    niche as yours. do some research and get some new ideas, never copy anyone else’s posts though, just get ideas. you will also find articles on these other blogs and these can also be very useful. by doing this you will…

  25. own ideas and different angles on a…

    topic. people who read your blog also read other blogs in your industry and are looking for new information and entertainment. try to make your blog fresh, informative and entertaining. this will ensure a growing number of readers for your blog.5….

  26. general public and catch the attention of…

    current and prospective writing clients are all smart ways to remain relevant and fresh about one’s writing talent. promoting your blog is probably the hardest part of the business. many people have what it takes to start a blog, to keep…

  27. in a comprehensive four-year program will give…

    you the opportunity to learn about general education subjects as well as a variety of journalism media. as a student in this discipline, you will become experienced with the fundamentals, from print to web, and even have the chance to capture…

  28. basic of it. i would like to…

    share more tips with you, but the format of the article is not suitable to cover all aspects in details. the way to write a good blog that gets real traffic is quite simple really. make it interesting, entertaining and informative…

  29. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…

  30. pdr tools says:

    ready to commit to a lifestyle change,…

    a healthier and leaner body can be achieved. and it doesn’t have to cost an arm and a leg nor does it have to involve drinking disgusting concoctions while fasting and feeling weak. as a matter of fact, the worst thing…

  31. writing posts for someone else’s blog also…

    helps you build your reputation in an industry. guest blogging brings you an opportunity to showcase your skills in the industry you cater to. if you want others in your niche market to identify you, posting articles on host blogs is…

  32. the idea is for you to be…

    individual in your blogging efforts, that becomes less of a problem.in other articles i will be delving further into some of the tools you can use to answer the questions i’ve just told you need sorting, plus i’ll cover other areas…

  33. not novelists? do we have more time…

    than everybody else? if you haven’t done so already my feeling is that you should try out novel writing software. maybe it gives you an edge. good article ideas to write about depends entirely upon how you plan to use the…

  34. in which they’re utilised in combination with…

    one another. as well as this, you will need a little bit of creative flair for making the whole setup as good as it possibly can be.while it may seem like a daunting task, there is no reason to start panicking….

  35. then tape these to the wall of…

    your office. these papers should include anything you will need to do for that week, personally. weekly or monthly appointments for administrative purposes should be put in your phone.#2: a yearly content focus schedule. a simple calendar, maybe on ano…

  36. hosting site for your blog, you could…

    have guaranteed clientele. you have higher chances of building high traffic and accumulate clicks that result to actual purchase. the question still begs though – which blog host out there could be beneficial?first of all, not all online marketers are …

  37. in activities that promote relaxation of both…

    the mind and body.bladder infection and stress incontinencebladder infections during this stage are often caused by diseases such as cystitis and urethritis. this causes women to experience burning sensations when they’re urinating as well as lower ba…

  38. relevant and useful. if you did please…

    share it with others who may find value in it as well. feel free to tweet it also.so that i may keep the content current and informative i’d appreciate it you also left your comments. that would be great.make it a…

  39. completion of your mba course, you can…

    now immediately apply for posts of higher level because you already have the skills that are mandatory for managers.in conclusion, an advance study is vitally important in order to get a higher recognition in the future. and even if you are…

  40. come here says:

    the task of web promotion by writing…

    articles does not provide samples, the buyer should ask for some; and • the contents must be written by someone who is familiar with the language.contents written by non-native writers in the companyif the seo article writing services is using a…

  41. … [Trackback]…

    [...] There you will find 3404 more Infos: eppc.org/publications/the-synapse-and-the-soul/ [...]…