Nietzsche vs. Intrinsic Human Worth

Commentary magazine | Published on

By Peter Wehner

Print Friendly


Jennifer Ratner-Rosenhagen, whose book American Nietzsche: A History of an Icon and His Ideas was reviewed in Commentary, published an essay in The Wilson Quarterly on how Friedrich Nietzsche was embraced by Americans eager to see in him a reflection of their own image. In summarizing the German philosopher’s views, Ratner-Rosenhagen writes:

Friedrich Nietzsche thought that if a culture was clutching calcified truths, one needed to sound them out relentlessly. And that’s exactly what he tried to do… this “philosopher with a hammer” (as he came to identify himself) spent his career tapping that hammer against Western ideals turned hollow idols. Central to his philosophical project was challenging the notion of eternal truth. Nietzsche sought to demonstrate that nothing is inherently good or evil, but rather that all values are culturally and historically contingent. Likewise, he argued that all claims to truth are nothing more than “human, all-too-human” desires for a particular version of the good life, not mirrors of a supra-historical reality.

While Nietzsche sought to dismantle the notion of universal morality, so too did he try to upend his readers’ faith in God. He shocked them with the declaration that “God is dead,” and disturbed them with his insistence that God had not created man in his image; it was man who had created an image of God in order to give his life meaning, purpose, and a moral center. According to Nietzsche, the entire basis of modern Western culture was a slippery slope of lies: transcendent truth, the Enlightenment faith in reason and scientific objectivity, absolute morality, a Supreme Maker. These were mere fictions, products of human imagination and the struggle for power.

From time to time, Nietzsche put down his hammer as he tried to imagine a world after moral absolutes. Even he wondered what would happen once every article of faith had been shed and every claim to universal truth exposed as a human construct.

Nietzsche was right to wonder, and Ranter-Rosenhagen’s work raises an old and enduring set of questions. Is there such a thing as a universal moral law, truths that are objective and permanent rather than subjective and contingent, ethical codes that are anchored in God rather than human choice, human desires, and human invention?

During the years, I’ve asked friends of mine, including several very intelligent and well-read atheists, the grounds on which a person who doesn’t believe in God makes the case for inherent human dignity. Absent a Creator, what is the argument against capriciousness, injustice, and tyranny? How does one create a system of justice and make the case against, say, slavery, if you begin with two propositions: one, the universe was created by chance; and two, it will end in nothing? How do you derive a belief in a moral law that is binding on you and others apart from theism? How do you get from the “is” to the “ought”?

To press the point a bit further, why would a materialist or a relativist have any confidence that their beliefs are (a) rooted in anything permanent and (b) applied to themselves and to others? It’s not obvious what the response is to a Nietzschean who says, “Your belief is fine for you, but it is simply non-binding on me. God is dead—and I choose to follow the Will to Power. You may not agree, but there is no philosophical or moral ground on which you can make your stand.”

Steve Hayner, president of Columbia Theological Seminary, once told me something that adds an important layer to this discussion. We believe we have worth because we are created in God’s image, he said. But even more basic is the declaration that we have value simply because God values us. Gold is valuable because someone values it, not because there is something about gold that is intrinsically of worth. Sure, gold is aesthetically beautiful and has particular physical qualities which set it apart (it is highly conductive, non-corroding, et cetera). But gold would not be valuable if it were not thought to be so by someone. In this case, value is attributive. Similarly, human beings are of worth simply because we are valued by God. Indeed, God demonstrated the value of humanity by His continuing involvement with us.

It is the attributive quality of worth which underlies Christian and Jewish anthropology. Comparative worth opens the door to an economic or utilitarian assessment of the value of an individual. Intrinsic worth may also be open to some debate. But attributive worth, according to Hayner, is not derived from culture or circumstances. Here, worth comes from the understanding that all people are precious in God’s sight.

It’s still unclear to me, then, on what basis we can argue that people can have intrinsic or attributive worth if we deny God and transcendent truth. I’m not claiming it can’t be done; I’m simply asking what a non-theistic moral code would be grounded in. Those who embrace atheism/anti-theism and the philosophy of Nietzsche would do well to understand, as he did, just how ugly and terrifying a world after moral absolutes would be.

It turns out taking a hammer to God doesn’t damage Him; but it does damage us.

Peter Wehner is a senior fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. Follow Mr. Wehner on Twitter at @Peter_Wehner .

Trackbacks

  1. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/nietzsche-vs-intrinsic-human-worth/ [...]…

  2. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/nietzsche-vs-intrinsic-human-worth/ [...]…

  3. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/nietzsche-vs-intrinsic-human-worth/ [...]…

  4. Trackback says:

    Thank you…

    Basically, I want it to be on the main page where all of my posts go but then I also want to be able to put it on a separate page of my blog dedicated to only that subject. Hopefully this makes sense!….

  5. Trackback says:

    Maybe……

    I wanna start a website about fantasy sports. I have lots of ideas for content…..

  6. Trackback says:

    Like it…

    I’m interested in making my own music blog and I’m constantly looking through many music blogs throughout the day finding new music first before other people that I know. But how exactly do those blogs find that music first? Can I really start by jus…

  7. this site says:

    Like it…

    I have a blog on blogger and every time i go to my blog it counts it as a page view even when im logged in. How do i make it only count the views from other people?….

  8. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Find More Informations here: eppc.org/publications/nietzsche-vs-intrinsic-human-worth/ [...]…

  9. penny stocks says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More Infos here: eppc.org/publications/nietzsche-vs-intrinsic-human-worth/ [...]…

  10. Trackback says:

    Great…

    Starting with registering the domain and designing the layout….

  11. rochii club says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] There you will find 34427 more Infos: eppc.org/publications/nietzsche-vs-intrinsic-human-worth/ [...]…

  12. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/nietzsche-vs-intrinsic-human-worth/ [...]…

  13. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/nietzsche-vs-intrinsic-human-worth/ [...]…

  14. vmofAeR1HT says:

    Whispering Misty…

    So sorry you can skip the workshop!…

  15. … [Trackback]…

    [...] There you will find 36276 more Infos: eppc.org/publications/nietzsche-vs-intrinsic-human-worth/ [...]…

  16. win online says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/nietzsche-vs-intrinsic-human-worth/ [...]…

  17. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Informations on that Topic: eppc.org/publications/nietzsche-vs-intrinsic-human-worth/ [...]…

  18. Thorn of Girl…

    Great information and facts can be identified on this internet website….

  19. some people just have the ability to…

    use reflections and pauses to affect the right response from the listener. the same is true for writing as the tone, organization, and style can engage or put the reader off, and that is where english composition comes into play.a course…

  20. Trackback says:

    Great…

    What is a blog subject that you would find interesting to read about?…

  21. Trackback says:

    Like it…

    How can I change to fluid width in the New Blogger Template Designer?…

  22. max garcinia says:

    product reviews to get your teeth into…

    just as you would reading an english language fashion blog and the material is vast. many posts are highly visual but there is a lot of good writing as well as interesting debate and thought in the comments posted. when it…

  23. you should explore different options. you could…

    become active in a couple of forums that have to do with the subject of your blog. most forums allow you a signature link and this should be a link back to your blog.another option is to use article marketing to…

  24. everyone – even in your chosen niche…

    - is a potential reader. that likely is not the case, and if it is you are probably focusing too broadly. you want to be able to clearly identify your readers. so much so that when creating content for your blog…

  25. can participate it but keep them as…

    close to your niche as possible. if you have a blog about snowboarding, people on a recipe forum are probably not going to care about the latest snowboard that burton just produced. the most popular types of sites will be other…

  26. urlman cow says:

    Healing’s Dragon…

    to discover issues to boost my website!I suppose its ok for making utilization of several of your respective ideas!!…

  27. glucogen says:

    reader can always just close the tab….

    after giving the reader something to react to (it can even be an excellently written post), make sure there is a simple way for them to respond. nowadays there are many easy to use commenting systems for blogs, make sure you…

  28. online writing jobs even without knowing seo,…

    but knowledge of it will bring you greater opportunities. most clients are looking for content that will drive up the web traffic to their sites, so they apply seo techniques when generating their content. if they decide to hire a writer,…

  29. communication as the exchange of information between…

    people. according to paul meyer, “communication – the human connection – is the key to personal and career success.” therefore, learning communication skills determines success in all endeavours. here are a few of the most basic fundamentals on commu…

  30. you are unsure about it, you could…

    get it edited by a professional. what you are providing should be informative and entertaining.the secret of good writing jobs has some rules to follow. you are reading this article. you obviously want to know the secret of becoming a successful…

  31. J Gateway says:

    details that will make the compass look…

    two or three times more valuable.3. luxury writing setshave you ever thought of giving writing materials as gifts? in this modern day and age, it is rare to even consider giving writing materials as gifts. but you can defy this budding…

  32. of subjects but in order for them…

    to sell, you must be able to offer new information to your customers.blogs can be used to build revenue. start with your chosen niche and market your blog to find the traffic you need. then, utilize these ideas to turn a…

  33. which indeed is a very special moment….

    on the other hand many mothers are quite unhappy because they tend to put on weight immediately after birth. so the best way forward is to fall under a diet pattern that enables reduction of weight gained during pregnancy. there are…

  34. pdr training says:

    it is said that there’s a book…

    inside everybody and so wordpress allows one to express oneself in a much more beautiful way. with a single bit of code to develop the typography of everyday writing wordpress was started in the year 2003. it’s a free blogging tool….

  35. website says:

    The Slave of the Husband…

    Searching for in advance to finding out additional from you afterward!……

  36. in increasing weight in the body. drinking…

    lots of water is also an important component to reduce weight post pregnancy. hence choosing the right diet should be left to the individual according to her tastes and requirements as long as it is within the overall objective of losing…

  37. this? the reason is that the best…

    way to get yourself known online is through back link creation. back link creation usually is possible through the submission of unique content articles to different article directories. if this content does not read well or is duplicate, your seo and…

  38. fast merchant cash advance leads…

    Get information about fast merchant cash advance leads on our site…

  39. fast cash advance loans no credit check…

    Visit our site and read about fast cash advance loans no credit check…

  40. guide here says:

    The Birch of the Shadow…

    I believe there may become a few duplicates, but an exceedingly helpful checklist! I’ve tweeted this. Many thanks for sharing!…

  41. an event that has interest and action,…

    with a little suspense if possible. narratives with no “problems” are usually not interesting. difficulty and solution is what makes any personal narrative enjoyable reading.i always have my students write their narrative rough draft in one sitting. …

  42. read here says:

    The Ships’s Voyages…

    I believe technologies just can make it worse. Now there is a channel to never ever treatment, now there wouldn’t be considered a chance for them to discover….

  43. here says:

    The Slave of the Husband…

    In search of in advance to studying more from you afterward!……

  44. short as possible. the ideal number for…

    a blog post is 300-400 words. avoid writing lengthy posts, people don’t have much time and cannot read your posts all day. instead, try to use some pictures. this way you can make your blog look more attractive.be consistentif you wish…

  45. nice way to earn extra money hosting…

    ads on a website you already maintain anyway. adsense pays you for visitor clicks to the advertised products and/or services.advertisers pay for the added exposure they receive from google, and you get a portion of that revenue by directing bloggers to…

  46. Great website…

    [...]we like to honor many other internet sites on the web, even if they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Under are some webpages worth checking out[...]……

  47. source here says:

    Healing’s Dragon…

    to uncover problems to boost my internet site!I suppose its alright for making use of some of your respective ideas!!…

  48. top free web directories…

    Very good Morning, I just stopped in to go to your site and believed I’d say I enjoyed myself….

  49. fast cash advance san antonio tx…

    Visit my site and get fast cash advance san antonio tx…

  50. web host reviews…

    Superb data is usually discovered on this internet website….

  51. the best blog hosting sites available today…

    you first take into consideration what the site has to offer. you take a comprehensive look at the features they provide, especially the ones that others don’t offer, or at least have better characteristics and qualities. some of the features you…

  52. blog says:

    Whispering Misty…

    So sorry you will skip the workshop!…

  53. more personal topics. the language in business…

    blogs tends to be more formal and more grammatically perfect. actually, no matter what sort of blog writing (or any writing at all) you post, the content should always be well written and error free. having mistakes (grammatical, punctuation, spelling,…

  54. in your own words and turn it…

    into a blog post. it doesn’t matter if you set up your blog for business or personal purposes; you have a blog because you want lots of people to read what you have to say. one way to drive readers to…

  55. view here says:

    site visitors into actual customers. * provide…

    unique and original content.blog writing will help generate traffic, increase sales and adds credibility to your business.a well maintained web log will surely increase your website’s visibility. you can easily connect to your customer base and build …

  56. scripts…

    So sorry you will miss the workshop!…

  57. website says:

    The Silent Shard…

    This could possibly be quite helpful for many of the work I want to never only with my blogging site but…

  58. Google says:

    Google…

    Usually posts some extremely intriguing stuff like this. If you’re new to this site….

  59. Websites worth visiting…

    [...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]……

  60. website says:

    The Birch of the Shadow…

    I believe there may possibly be a couple of duplicates, but an exceedingly useful listing! I’ve tweeted this. A lot of thanks for sharing!…

  61. iUnlox – Official iPhone IMEI Factory Unlocking Service…

    Do you want to know how to unlock your iPhone 4 permanently with an official IMEI factory unlock? Unlock any iPhone model running any release of baseband. iPhone Network unlocks are permanent, processed by Apple, completed in iTunes and do not void you…

  62. website says:

    The Birch of the Shadow…

    I think there may perhaps be a handful of duplicates, but an exceedingly useful record! I’ve tweeted this. Lots of thanks for sharing!…

  63. residences says:

    residences…

    So sorry you can pass up the workshop!…

  64. website says:

    The Ships’s Voyages…

    I think engineering just makes it worse. Now there’s a channel to by no means treatment, now there won’t become a opportunity for them to find out….

  65. check my pagerank…

    This can likely be pretty beneficial for some of one’s work I intend to you should not only with my weblog but…