Catholic Conservatives and the Common Good

The Catholic Thing | Published on

By Stephen P. White

Print Friendly


Catholics self-styled as “progressive” have enjoyed a virtual monopoly on the more communal terms in Catholic social teaching: common good, solidarity, social justice, and preferential option for the poor. These principles are integral to a fully Catholic understanding of society and the role of the state. Meanwhile, Catholics of a more conservative bent have emphasized other aspects of the Church's social doctrine: subsidiarity, the dignity of the individual, and the creative power of markets.

While these latter, personalist principles are essential to a genuine Catholic social teaching, without the communitarian dimension, the view from the Right tends to devolve into a quasi-libertarian and, often, overtly ideological imitation of Church teaching. At the same time, the Left's approach underemphasizes subsidiarity and the rights of mediating institutions; its old statist habits tend to subsume everything under the crushing embrace of government.

Accordingly, both the communitarian and personalist elements of the Church's social teaching have widely come to be seen through the lens of a political partisanship—i.e. the personalist and communitarian “schools” of Catholic social thought tend to reduce to quasi-libertarian and quasi-socialist positions, which closely mirror their respective political counterparts. Such stunted accounts of the principles of Catholic social teaching are unhelpful and morally inadequate.

Unlike political ideologies of the Right and Left, personalist and communitarian principles are not fundamentally opposed, but complementary. Libertarians and socialists may adhere to incompatible ideologies, but for Catholics, the common good is never “in tension with” (let alone opposed to) the dignity and proper autonomy of the individual person. Subsidiarity is not “balanced against” solidarity. The erosion of solidarity always endangers subsidiarity. In the absence of subsidiarity, solidarity is smothered by dependence upon the state. The dignity of the individual can never be sacrificed in the name of collective utility, and no true individual good can be legitimately won at the expense of the common good.

Those like President Obama, who insist that the measure—indeed, the necessary condition—of national greatness is our willingness and ability to care for the weakest among us are entirely correct. Where reasonable people of good will can and do disagree, is on the question of how our society, and thus the state, should fulfill our commitments to the poor and marginalized.

It's an astonishing failure of political imagination (or an extraordinary act of historical hubris) to insist that the only moral means for promoting the common good are to be found in the expansion of the massive social assistance programs devised in the middle of the twentieth century, the costs of which have put this country on the road to insolvency.

If more taxes and government spending were in fact better for society, it would be irresponsible to oppose them. If a larger, more active state with an expansive welfare apparatus constituted the social arrangement most conducive to the common good, we would, at least from a Catholic point of view, be morally bound to support it. Yet as a matter of empirical evidence and prudential judgment, not ideological preference, the current system is, to say the least, not entirely convincing.

So does this “canonize” the policies proposed by conservatives? No. But if promotion of the common good is the ultimate measure of social justice, then proposals for entitlement reform like those recently put forward by Congressman Paul Ryan and passed by the House have a strong claim over the recent proposals of President Obama—and precisely on the grounds that they better promote social justice and the common good.

Two decades ago, welfare reform succeeded, not because of some national neo-libertarian change of heart in the American polity, but because it became plain that our welfare programs, as they existed, were grossly counter-productive, indeed harmful to the very communities they had been designed to help and were harming the wider community in the process.

Many progressive Catholics worried that welfare reform would make things worse for the disadvantaged, and so would violate the Church's preferential option for the poor. Instead, as President Clinton pointed out in 2006 writing in The New York Times, as welfare rolls fell, “child poverty dropped to 16.2 percent in 2000, the lowest rate since 1979, and in 2000, the percentage of Americans on welfare reached its lowest level in four decades.”

We have again reached, or are very near to reaching, another such tipping point. Many progressives are again warning that reform of government entitlements would be an abdication of moral responsibility, a betrayal of the common good. If the entitlement reforms this country desperately requires are going to succeed—and it seems that any such reform will have to come from conservatives—those who would lead that reform must be able to make a compelling case that entitlement reforms serve not only individuals but the common good. (The recent exchange between Congressman Ryan and Archbishop Timothy Dolan of New York makes for a good start.)

Catholics genuinely interested in promoting the fullness of the Church's social teachings must give better accounts of how their favored policies work. Policies that defend subsidiarity and free markets while promoting individual liberty and responsibility are good and necessary. But advocates of these social goods should not neglect those arguments—by far the greater, both politically and morally—that defend the good of all while working in accord with the Founders' hope of a “more perfect Union.”

Stephen P. White, a new contributor to The Catholic Thing, works in the Catholic Studies Program at the Ethics and Public Policy Center in Washington, D.C., where he has been the coordinator of the Tertio Millennio Seminar on the Free Society since 2005. He studies philosophy at the Catholic University of America.

This article first appeared on “The Catholic Thing” (www.thecatholicthing.org), copyright 2011, all rights reserved.

Trackbacks

  1. URL says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/catholic-conservatives-and-the-common-good/ [...]…

  2. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/catholic-conservatives-and-the-common-good/ [...]…

  3. Trackback says:

    Great…

    I’m having some problems with Firefox, so I want to uninstall it and then reinstall it. But I want to save all my bookmarks, so can I save my bookmarks to my computer, and then import them back to Firefox once I reinstall it? Thanks for the help…..

  4. Trackback says:

    I have some question…

    WordPress is up and running on my host — but it completely mismatches my site’s existing theme/CSS. How hard would it be to modify/write a new theme to make it fit in? Is there an easier way to do this?….

  5. Trackback says:

    I have some question…

    I’m going to start a serious blog that will eventually hold a great deal of content. I am a graphic designer, and my husband does my web programming, so this is for reals (haha, yes I just said that). That being said, I’ve already started collecting …

  6. this site says:

    I like your blog…

    You are a poor junior professor of computer science and are short of cash.. A computer magazine offers you a steady side job writing. one short article a month for three years. 36 months. The catch is the editor wants you to write about. the 12 differe…

  7. Trackback says:

    Maybe……

    I have a friend that needs to raise $35, 000 to get out of debt after being laid off. This would give her the fresh start on life since there are not many jobs in this area she could move and start over. I would like to help her and start a website for…

  8. sms lån says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Find More Informations here: eppc.org/publications/catholic-conservatives-and-the-common-good/ [...]…

  9. Thorn of Girl…

    Great data is usually uncovered on this online blog….

  10. Trackback says:

    Funny…

    I’m only 15, but i’m trying to raise money to go on a expensive trip next year. I am planning on getting a summer job, but it usually only pays minimum wage. I just want other people’s opinions on whether its safe and a good idea to become a blogger…

  11. The Ships’s Voyages…

    I feel technologies just can make it worse. Now there’s a channel to never ever treatment, now there is not going to become a probability for them to find out….

  12. Trackback says:

    I like your blog…

    What is the difference between a blog and a website?…

  13. Trackback says:

    I like your blog…

    How to make my second blog my default one on Tumblr?…

  14. Trackback says:

    Funny…

    I know that there are countless plug-ins designed to make the comments do-follow, but I’m looking for something that will make the links in the blog-posts themselves do-follow. Please include a link or detailed instructions on how to do this. Thanks!….

  15. Trackback says:

    wow thats great…

    I want to start a fashion/lifestyle blog. I love photography, but I want to upgrade my digital camera to a more professional one. I also wanted to start this blog, so which camera would you recommend me. I have a small budget, so if you could find some…

  16. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Informations on that Topic: eppc.org/publications/catholic-conservatives-and-the-common-good/ [...]…

  17. Trackback says:

    Funny…

    I see in my blog trackers significant traffic coming from facebook. My blog is not connected with facebook, I don’t have an account there, and I can’t see, who posts the links… any ideas?….

  18. Trackback says:

    I have some question…

    I don’t see a prompt or indication about how to start writing a blog. I want to know how to initiate one. Thank you…..

  19. The Silent Shard…

    This will probably be really valuable for many within your employment I plan to do not only with my blogging site but…

  20. Trackback says:

    Thank you…

    In general, how many blog posts have images out of all the blog posts in all blogs?. I’m looking for an average number for the US and worldwide…..

  21. free bonus says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/catholic-conservatives-and-the-common-good/ [...]…

  22. Trackback says:

    Thank you…

    I want to start a website where i can put google adds on, i have 10 dollars to spend and i know that isn’t a lot but it is better than those free websites that don’t let you do anything. so how do i get started?….

  23. Woman of Alien…

    Excellent get the job done you have got carried out, this site is basically cool with excellent information. Time is God’s method of retaining everything from happening at once….

  24. … [Trackback]…

    [...] There you will find 37925 more Infos: eppc.org/publications/catholic-conservatives-and-the-common-good/ [...]…

  25. fznygolm says:

    fznygolm…

    Catholic Conservatives and the Common Good – Ethics & Public Policy Center…

  26. uivvqqku says:

    uivvqqku…

    Agree with your words. Hope you can keep update your post. I wanna back. thank you!…

  27. The Ships’s Voyages…

    I think engineering just causes it to be worse. Now there’s a channel to hardly ever care, now there will not likely be a chance for them to discover….

  28. Dentist IL says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Informations on that Topic: eppc.org/publications/catholic-conservatives-and-the-common-good/ [...]…

  29. page’s url and write the funny words…

    in the anti-spam box, and it will tell you the rank. it even shows you a little green bar that visually represents the pagerank just in case you can’t interpret a number.to give you a basic idea, anything under pagerank 4…

  30. to your blog and help rate you…

    higher in the page rank and search engines. plus, do not forget, your readers want something new, so keep them on the edge of their seat wanting more. if you are away, let your readers know, and if you are busy,…

  31. two types of advertising and both can…

    be used.the first type of advertising program that bloggers can use is google adsense. this program offers many different services to increase adverting opportunities. you make money when a viewer clicks a certain ad that appears on your blog when your…

  32. your blog? is it getting enough viewers…

    and followers? yes, you may have written some excellent blog posts that you’re sure your readers are going to love, but are you doing enough to promote your blog?though you can be putting great content out there, you may have forgotten…

  33. knowledgeable about it. are you in pursuit…

    of good ideas and tips to get the company blog started? looking for ways to inculcate and integrate the 4ps of marketing? inquire if the marketing department of your company is planning to enter the blog-sphere with a fresh company blog….

  34. thing you might want to do is…

    sort through the details to make a pithy blog post.ghost writers can write your blog while you spend your time in other ways to help the business. if joe m. movie is a famous director who had directed dozens of successful…

  35. workers?most website owners, or the people requiring…

    the write ups for any other reasons, are usually busy people. so it is not likely that they can get time to sit down and write the information peacefully and cool-headedly. besides, there are many people who are pretty good with…

  36. another very effective method of gaining online…

    recognition and making money is to join a reputable and reliable web content provider company. it will be good to check out whether the site has high volume traffic movements and are doing well online.following the guidelines of the company after…

  37. and you can ask to get some…

    samples from the writers that have the right experience for your project. take a look at these samples and just feel them. if you see flexibility and a tone that sounds right to you, you can move on to the next…

  38. Sky Woods says:

    quality content to boost your website traffic….

    the cell phone has crept or really jumped into everyone’s life. for many people, especially teenagers, texting is their oxygen supply to the world. many kids would rather do anything than lose their texting privileges.since unlimited texting was intro…

  39. make a habit of writing english everyday.once…

    you get those writing resource materials, whether they are books or internet courses, set a daily schedule for yourself to sit down and practice writing for at least thirty minutes. do not skip over what you think you may already know…

  40. also includes small party buses. the limousine…

    blog shows a strategic planner how to make most efficient and economical use of all vehicles. in fact, the bigger the event or the bigger the name on the marquee, the more an event planner ought to avail herself of the…

  41. information you wish share with your readers,…

    many bloggers also like to add in images and videos.put yourself in the reader’s shoesthis article will look at the secrets of writing great posts for your blog. as i always say, behind every successful blogger is good content, repeatedly written….

  42. pdr training says:

    and efficient. but which writing courses would…

    be the best to help you to achieve this?choosing the best course will be very important to help you develop your writing skills in the right direction. because certainly, if you want to develop your skills in writing reports and simplifying…

  43. of course, each blogger has their own…

    idea of success, but most set goals for high traffic and receiving more feedback on their content. if you’re determined that your blog can be successful, if you’re willing to spend the necessary time to create compelling content, and perhaps most…

  44. pdr tools says:

    have established yourself as a good quality,…

    trustworthy, blogger.how does a person establish themselves as a quality blogger? you can help establish yourself by continuing to add interesting and useful content to your blog, even if you don’t have many readers, and implementing various strategie…

  45. with the outside world. when the idea…

    of creating or maintaining a successful blog seems like too much to handle, blog post writers for hire are available to get the job done quickly, professionally and affordably.freelance blog writers for hirethere are thousands of individuals around the…

  46. want people to go there. this is…

    especially true if you are dabbling in internet marketing and using any of the web pages for a product. because the means of traffic on the internet do not really change, you can use these traffic techniques on any of the…

  47. content writing is a core part of…

    online marketing today. effective website content that is search engine optimized using relevant keywords plays a huge role in achieving online business success. it not only promotes a business’s brand image but also increases visibility for online bu…

  48. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/catholic-conservatives-and-the-common-good/ [...]…

  49. of almost every business.with blogs, you can…

    be informal and relate better with visitorsvisitors come to a business blog expecting to learn something other than what is presented on the main website. this is where a smart businessperson can go for the kill. business blogging is a good…

  50. about how you will measure success. most…

    importantly, communicate how your proposed plans and programs will transform lives. you are asking a grant maker to give you money; be sure your reader can see the impact that decision will have. in summary, some technical writing skills can help…

  51. cool site says:

    interest readers and provoke curiosity.up to date…

    informationthe blogosphere is a fast evolving world and there is no space for stale, outdated content. to make a mark, your blog posts must contain the most updated information in the cyber world. facebook posts are going to be your key…

  52. can be most effective for you.it’s always…

    nice to have choices, and when it comes to finding the best blog software you’ve got many. just keep the overall objectives in your mind when attempting to decide which is the best for you. for probably the most part, if…