Bush’s NASA Revolution

National Review Online, July 20, 2004 | Published on

By Adam Keiper

Print Friendly


Exactly 35 years ago, on July 20, 1969, the “Eagle” landed and Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin became the first men to walk on the moon. It was a risky mission, like any great adventure into the unknown — so risky that William Safire, then a White House speechwriter, drafted a never-delivered just-in-case speech for President Richard Nixon, to tell the nation that “Fate has ordained that the men who went to the moon to explore in peace will stay on the moon to rest in peace.”

But ours was a nation unafraid of risk, unfrightened by the possibility of failure. Unlike the Soviet space program, which was buried in layers of secrecy and propaganda, the Apollo 11 mission was televised around the world, so that millions of people watched the culmination in “one small step for man, one giant leap for mankind.”

In all, twelve men — all Americans — walked on the moon between 1969 and 1972. No one has gone back since then; instead, we’ve done all our exploring with robots (like the rovers presently on Mars, or the Cassini probe now photographing Saturn), while humans have been confined to Earth orbit.

That’s all changing. Since President Bush’s announcement in January of his vision to “gain a new foothold on the moon and to prepare for new journeys to the worlds beyond our own,” NASA has been transforming itself into an agency capable once again of going places — of exploring space instead of just floating around our own planet. According to the president’s timetable, a new series of robotic missions to the moon will start by 2008, and human exploration of the moon will resume some time between 2015 and 2020.

In other words, American astronauts may be back on the lunar surface in time for the 50th anniversary of the first moon landing. This brings to mind three related questions. First, what caused the long delay — that is, what happened to keep us from the moon since 1972? Second, why is it going to take so long to get back to the moon this time — perhaps twice as long as the eight years it took last time? And finally, why should we bother going at all?

As the Apollo 11 astronauts were hurtling from the moon back toward home, NASA officials expressed the optimism of many Americans. “It seems quite clear,” said George Mueller, NASA associate administrator, “that the planets of the solar system are well within our ability to explore, both manned and unmanned, at the present time.” Even allowing for the enormous exaggeration in the last four words of Mueller’s statement, it would have been inconceivable to most people watching the live coverage of Apollo 11 on TV that we wouldn’t reach Mars before the end of the century, that we would retreat from the moon after a few short years, and that our great adventure in space would shrivel into just a fragile space shuttle and a half-built space station.

There are many explanations for NASA’s decline. Some have said NASA lost its “can-do” spirit and became just another bureaucracy, losing its ability to achieve great things. Others have argued that we only succeeded in the 1960s because of the spur of competition; after we beat the Soviets in the race to the moon, we lost the impetus for further exploration; NASA was thus a victim of its own success. Some critics have blamed NASA’s apparent mediocrity on a lack of public attention; others have blamed a lack of political will.

Each of those explanations is partially true: the public and its leaders lost interest, NASA lost sight of big goals, and the agency got tired and sloppy with age. But the chief problem has been much more fundamental: a failure to understand and articulate why we should go into space. The board that investigated the accident that destroyed the shuttle Columbia last year summed up the problem nicely, finding “a lack, over the past three decades, of any national mandate providing NASA a compelling mission requiring human presence in space.” The board recommended in its final report “that the White House, Congress, and NASA should honor the memory of Columbia‘s crew by reflecting on the nation’s future in space and the role of new space transportation capabilities in enabling whatever space goals the nation chooses to pursue.”

Now President Bush has given NASA a new mission, and work is already well underway to reorganize the agency to focus on that mission. A number of major changes to the structure of NASA will take effect on August 1, 2004, including clearer lines of accountability and a great deal of streamlining in NASA’s headquarters and bureaucracy.

Congress has not yet had much to say about the president’s plan or NASA’s reorganization, but since this is an election year, some opposition is to be expected. The chief gripe of the plan’s opponents has been that the president’s goal of exploring space is too extravagant, too expensive, too wasteful — but it is space activity done without a goal that results in waste. And even if opponents criticize the cost or quibble over the details of the president’s plan, a larger point is undeniable: NASA cannot be allowed to revert to its old ways, to the ethos of aimlessness. There can be no going back to the days before President Bush’s speech, or before the Columbia accident.

Nor, though, can we go back to the days of Apollo — which explains why it may take as long as 16 years to get to the moon this time, when it only took eight years to get to the moon after President Kennedy’s 1961 announcement. Inside the space community, the Apollo lunar landings, for all their wondrous achievement, are sometimes derided as mere “flags-and-footprints” missions, just for show. Now, however, the president has set us on a path toward long-term exploration and permanent outposts. This time, we’re going to stay. Surely the new space program could have a tighter timeline, and we could return to the moon and move on to Mars more quickly than the president’s plan presently calls for — but if we’re seriously committed to a future in space, we have to develop a careful plan and reliable hardware that will not just get us there, but will let us stay.

All that remains is the final question: Why should we go at all? There are valid scientific and economic reasons for space exploration, but the chief justification is difficult to express — at least, that is, without sounding corny. It has to do with American creativity — with our vast technical expertise and our most innovative minds bent upon solving difficult problems. It has to do with American character — the call of the frontier and the courage of the pioneer. And it has to do with American greatness — the daring of the hero, the risk of the adventure, and the glory of a future worthy of the people of this nation.

Adam Keiper is managing editor of The New Atlantis: A Journal of Technology and Society.

Trackbacks

  1. Maybe……

    Is it possible to hide certain blog posts on Blogger? If so, how?.. I know that I can save my post as a draft, or have it scheduled, but what I need is to hide my post for a giveaway but still have certain followers be able to access it through a link….

  2. Trackback says:

    Thank you…

    How to make a spoiler button in blogger blog posts?…

  3. Trackback says:

    Maybe……

    I have a blog that’s private, so no one else sees it, but I still want to make it look nice. How can I personalize my blog without fucking it all up?….

  4. Trackback says:

    I have some question…

    How can I access my home computer that is hooked up to a router through my work computer to view webcam?…

  5. I have some question…

    What is the best way to start a Blog for profit?…

  6. Trackback says:

    I have some question…

    How could I write blogs or articles and get paid for it?…

  7. Souls in the Waves…

    Great Morning, I just stopped in to visit your web site and believed I would say I loved myself….

  8. turn into a visual delight on the…

    silver screen.the advantages that teamwork has are too many to list but consist mainly of:* the step-by-step compilation becomes a breeze * innovative ideas take shape and are pitched together to produce excellent results * working becomes effortless a…

  9. an rss feed to stay current about…

    publishing house requirements.some publishing houses i was interested in had email notification service for industry news, like a shuffle in the editorial line up or brand new book series looking for fresh stories, which helped just as much as the ones…

  10. everyday lesson and a beautiful advantage.we are…

    not superior over others; it is just some people think that way. yet in america, writing a single blog post is a responsibility, for the chance of it being read by the rest of the world is like jaywalking on the…

  11. not everyone will make it to the…

    top of the blogging pyramid. in fact, little more than half of the blog writers out there will gain the notoriety that those who participate in blog writing want. but, if you create a blog that will set you apart from…

  12. to put togethercreating a quality newsletter does…

    take some additional time. you don’t want to just send you readers your rss feed for the week. they’ve already read your blog. you want to send your subscribers content that’s even better, if possible. your newsletter has their complete undivided…

  13. the big corporate houses. most of them…

    later on become entrepreneurs in spite of their respective fields of expertise. either way having expertise in managerial skill will help you in a lot of ways.master’s in business administration involves motivating employees, decision-making, supervis…

  14. did you ever wonder how they got…

    to guest post and why they wanted to? do they get paid? what’s the incentive? the truth is you can make money writing guest posts. it may or may not be direct income, but if you love to write, it is…

  15. a firm grasp oh how to compose…

    your writings. this quick guide will show you how to become a better writer regardless of the genre that you write for.writing is a creative process. being a writer is more than just being able to spell correctly and use grammar…

  16. long term. by long term i mean…

    several years.who should do the blogging?the question of who should write your company’s blog posts hinges to a great extent on the size and nature of your company. because blogging is like brand building in that it doesn’t directly generate sales,…

  17. your writing skills. perhaps try to test…

    your skills by creating some articles on your own and posting them on your blog. if you get a good number of interested readers, then you are probably ready to take writing projects from here. let’s say that you are a…

  18. for you to apply or to bid…

    on. more often, these outsourcing sites will require you to provide personal information such as your e-mail phone numbers, upload an image for your profile and attach a resume or your updated cv. such information may be available for public or…

  19. your mobile phone so you’ve got no…

    excuses.blogging platform publishing toolsi touched on this in the previous point. if you post once per day, you don’t have to do all of the work on that day. if you want to write 7 days worth of posts in one…

  20. along with synonyms and also antonyms, contextual…

    spelling. there is a text enrichment facility which suggests adjectives, adverbs that can improve the sentences. words which are correctly spelled but used in incorrect context can be detected easily and we can make corrections. our english vocabulary …

  21. using affiliate programs. no matter the case,…

    you should start using adsense in your business right away.so even if you know nothing about html, scripting, or inserting code into your blog, you don’t have to worry – blogger takes care of all of this for you. all you…

  22. best solution to your problem. the same…

    answer keeps appearing, “find and hire a quality ghostwriter.” so you may be reading this to find an answer to your question and hopefully a fix for your problem. let’s break down the whole process from beginning to end.what the heck…

  23. Google says:

    Google…

    The details talked about in the write-up are a number of the most effective available….

  24. Trackback says:

    Like it…

    I’m just having this crazy idea, I’m planning to post comic pages or strips on Blogger, since its generating revenue from Google Adsense, I might profit from this, hehe (me gloating like an alien Ferengi). Will this idea work?….

  25. earn serious money and somehow, get by….

    some may sound odd while some is considered no sweat. just remember, if you’re not comfortable doing it, you can always pass.start a part-time business. you don’t need a big capital to start a business. sometimes, you can start with next…

  26. kosiarki says:

    say they want to make money with…

    their blog, but they don’t subscribe and/or follow other successful people. also look for successful people in your niche in social media and google. it won’t be hard to find the popular people. study their content and watch how they engage…