All the President’s Mandate Positions

National Review Online | Published on June 27, 2012

By James C. Capretta

Print Friendly


Obamacare’s apologists and their allies in the mainstream press have spent an inordinate amount of time and energy dissecting the supposed hypocrisy of conservatives on the individual mandate. They are indignant that the GOP is now in lockstep opposition to the mandate even though two decades ago some Republican senators—most of whom have long since departed from the scene—supported the concept in theory in large part to fight against even heavier-handed government intrusion into the health sector by President Clinton. How transparently political and outrageous of them!

But it’s hard to take these attacks seriously when those launching them systematically ignore the much more important, immediate, and consequential flip-flopping on this issue by their health-care hero, President Obama.

The president’s contortions on the individual mandate didn’t take place two decades ago and didn’t evolve over a period of years. He changed his position abruptly in early 2009 after he was elected president, just months after taking a hardline position on the opposing side during the entirety of the presidential campaign. And it’s a safe bet that, if the outcome of the Supreme Court’s decision on Obamacare makes it convenient for him, he will change his position yet again. Indeed, if recent history is any guide, he will do so with nary a peep from an adoring press.

The story of the president’s…evolution…on this issue begins in early 2008. Then-senator Barack Obama was locked in a bitter struggle with his Senate rival, Hillary Clinton, for the Democratic presidential nomination. On most issues, there was no discernible space between them, with both staking out traditional liberal positions on the various issues of import to Democratic primary voters.

But on health care, Senator Obama saw an opportunity. He had put out a health-care plan that checked all of the boxes of the standard Democratic approach to reform: expand Medicaid, provide new subsidies for insurance coverage, require employers to offer plans, and establish a new “public option” modeled on Medicare. But he left off of his list one crucial item: the individual mandate.

This was no small matter. Without the mandate, the Obama plan would not be considered a “universal coverage” plan in Democratic circles, as analysts, including those at the Congressional Budget Office, would expect large numbers of Americans to decline to sign up for coverage in a voluntary system. Party elites and activists would regard this as a major, perhaps even fatal, flaw. Nothing in the Democratic catechism is more sacred than the goal of “universal coverage” in health care.

So Senator Obama was taking a risk in not toeing the party line. But it was a calculated risk. He knew from polling data that, despite its popularity among party elites and left-leaning health-care analysts, the individual mandate was far less popular among Democratic primary voters. Here was a policy difference with Senator Clinton that he could exploit to his advantage in the primaries.

And exploit it he did. In ads, mailings, and debates, Senator Obama in the crucial months of the campaign hammered Senator Clinton for forcing people who couldn’t afford premiums to pay them anyway or face sanctions from the federal government. And, from Senator Clinton’s indignant reaction, it’s safe to say the attacks hit the mark.

Now, fast-forward to late 2008 and early 2009, as Senator Obama was on the road to becoming President Obama. The November election could not have gone better for the Democrats. Obama won his race against John McCain handily, and the incoming 111th Congress would have commanding Democratic majorities in both houses, giving the president essentially free rein to enact a sweeping agenda. Democratic activists across the board were salivating at the prospect of using those majorities to finally push through a “universal coverage” health-care plan.

But there was a small problem. The Obama plan didn’t have a mandate and therefore wasn’t “universal coverage.”

What to do? Change positions, of course. By December 2008, just weeks after the election, rumors were already circulating to that effect. By spring 2009, as initial drafts of the legislation were being assembled in Congress, the administration made it official that the president was changing his position and would push for the mandate.

Some journalists have tried to paper over this head-spinning flip-flop as simply a matter of new and better information. According to the account popularized by Ryan Lizza’s pieces in The New Yorker, the president received a memo in April 2009 explaining that official estimates would show that, at a cost that was only slightly higher, a health-care plan with the mandate would cover millions more people than would a voluntary program. That is said to have changed the president’s mind.

This is nonsense. It was always known that a plan with a mandate would do better on coverage numbers than would one without it. That was the whole point of the mandate: It would force millions to use their private resources to buy coverage and thereby increase the number of the insured without too much more public spending. This was not new information in 2009. Senator Obama chose to oppose the mandate in 2008 because it was politically expedient. In 2009, he changed his position because he found it advantageous. It’s as simple as that.

Since its enactment two years ago, the individual mandate has been challenged in federal court on constitutional grounds. The Obama administration has filed brief after brief in these cases, arguing that the mandate is essential to the operation of the rest of the law. Indeed, somewhat surprisingly, the administration has gone so far as to tell the various courts, including the U.S. Supreme Court, that if the mandate were to fall, then community rating and guaranteed issue would have to go too because, without the mandate, these provisions would destroy the private insurance market.

Why would the administration take such a position, which might expose even more of the law to the risk of an adverse court ruling? For political reasons, of course. The administration’s lawyers were attempting to turn up the heat on the judges by essentially telling them that they couldn’t kill just the unpopular provision in the law; they would have to take out the popular ones, too.

But what if the Supreme Court ignores the administration’s request and kills just the individual mandate? Would the administration continue to adhere to the logic of its legal briefs and go back to Congress for fixes to prevent the destruction of the private insurance industry?

Don’t count on it. If the Court goes that route, expect the president and the administration to turn on a dime and, on the day of the court ruling, to adopt an entirely new position regarding the mandate. If it goes, they will claim they never really needed it anyway to make the law work and that they have the tools they need to sign up nearly all Americans to affordable insurance. In other words: Full steam ahead! This new administration line is already being tested by trusted surrogates.

President Obama isn’t the first politician to shift his position on an important issue when it was politically convenient for him to do so, and he won’t be the last. But he has done it in a particularly brazen manner, complaining all the while that it’s his political opponents who are craven opportunists. Perhaps he’s just delivering the audacity he promised when running for office.

James C.
Capretta is a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. He was an associate director at
the Office of Management and Budget from 2001 to 2004.

Trackbacks

  1. … [Trackback]…

    [...] There you will find 89508 more Infos: eppc.org/publications/all-the-presidents-mandate-positions/ [...]…

  2. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Informations on that Topic: eppc.org/publications/all-the-presidents-mandate-positions/ [...]…

  3. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More Infos here: eppc.org/publications/all-the-presidents-mandate-positions/ [...]…

  4. bescherming says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/all-the-presidents-mandate-positions/ [...]…

  5. Learn More says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/all-the-presidents-mandate-positions/ [...]…

  6. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More Infos here: eppc.org/publications/all-the-presidents-mandate-positions/ [...]…

  7. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: eppc.org/publications/all-the-presidents-mandate-positions/ [...]…

  8. casino says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More Infos here: eppc.org/publications/all-the-presidents-mandate-positions/ [...]…

  9. Trackback says:

    Thank you…

    I have asked a question similar to this topic before and was helped out, but now id like to get specific. In the beginning of the movie he (Mark) posts on a blog as he works on the girl rating site, “FaceMash”, and as well as bash his ex girlfriend h…

  10. Trackback says:

    Funny…

    How would I go about creating a new blog that could become successful in less than a year. I have a lot of ideas of different things I could include, so I don’t know that content would be an issue. What are good ways to promote a new blog and is it be…

  11. Trackback says:

    I like your blog…

    I got two networked blog setting of a single blog in facebook. I want to delete of them. Is there any way to delete only one networked blog keeping the another as it is?….

  12. companies commit the lethal mistake of thinking…

    that not working hard for a pqq won’t matter so much and that they can show their true calibre in the tender document stage itself. guess what? such companies don’t even get to see the tender stage only. for, any client…

  13. submit original content written by yourself. let’s…

    face it, if you are a want to be blogger and you are having a tough time creating unique and original content, you may want to look at doing something else for a living.other organic methods to attract blog traffic might…

  14. your blog. these are very important because…

    having a large network of active links to you site will give you a much larger web presence, which generates more traffic for your blog. however, make sure that your links are on articles which are relevant to what your blog…

  15. blog being able to spread virally. there…

    are some facebook widgets, but you need to access the actual posts in order to view them. i just don’t think that is adequate enough.with wordpress, the statistics they provide are also limited to how many all-time visitors you’ve had to…

  16. cantik alami says:

    not focus on any of them. design…

    also applies to how you lay out your text. use brief, simple paragraphs and sentences to keep a natural, easy read, and move the reader’s eye on down the page.step two – add imagesin a blog post, unlike an article, you…

  17. an ongoing chronicle of information. a blog…

    contains diary type commentaries and they range from personal to business to political and so on. they can focus on a whole range of subjects or on a particular one.there are many sites available for blogging, one of which is wordpress….

  18. make the most of your blog several…

    factors should be considered. you cannot just go and post a blog anywhere and expect to become popular overnight. it just will not happen. there are certain things you will need to do in order to have a successful blog. here…

  19. others who may find value in it…

    as well. feel free to tweet it also.so that i may keep the content current and informative i’d appreciate it you also left your comments. that would be great.make it a great day.p.s. the majority of the content above can be…

  20. your article writing skills, try taking a…

    step back to basics. this means having a simple and easy to remember structure, using common words and shorter sentences, and presenting a limited amount of simple ideas. simplify your article writing with these concepts, to take your article writing t…

  21. be important for you to find out…

    more information on how to write a good seo article. there are some guidelines that need to be followed in order to get the very best article that can pull up your blog online.one of the things to keep in mind…

  22. truth in that statement. numerous books have…

    become bestsellers because they were marketed well, but anyone who reads a lot can probably come up with a half-dozen books he or she has read that were bestsellers but were truly awful books. those readers were dazzled by the marketing-it…

  23. take a look below and apply these…

    5 practical tips for choosing a good writer for your magazine, website or blog pertaining to architecture or interior design.tip #1 – check with the writer for past experience in your nichewhile a basic interest in architecture styles, trends, techniqu…

  24. must be able to address or answer…

    the questions, problems, issues and queries faced by the target audience.thought provoking and compelling contentin too many cases, blog posts fall flat on the faces because they don’t provide anything new to think about or discuss. a great way to dra…

  25. and services they recommend.i have something to…

    say, therefore i blogsimilar to the last category, but i’d put blogs about news, politics, and gossip here. huffington post is an example.i have something to sell, therefore i blogonline marketers know that running a blog is a great way to…

  26. your information about your blog.now this is…

    very important to remember that you want to attract subscribers to your blog.the first question will be asked is your rss feed link it will be like this; yourdomain.com/feed so like i was saying, you are going to have to be…

  27. easily passed on to others when it…

    is in writing.the ability for your message to be permanent, compelling, and shareable is very powerful. don’t dilute your message by slacking on the basic rules of spelling, grammar, and punctuation. rather, master these fundamentals to make your mess…

  28. their performance at work.blogging – whether public…

    or private – helps you, your staff and ultimately your business. and the research shows people only need to blog twice a week to have a significant impact on psychological status. so why wouldn’t you encourage it in your company? your…

  29. have unlimited space but they have excellent…

    support.webhostingpadwebhostingpad has really cheap prices for hosting. you’ll find that they might even be the cheapest online. the servers are reliable and they have really good support. they are not very popular but in time this might change due to…

  30. this is an frequently overlooked point when…

    posting an update, even though it is significant if you would like to receive the most activity as possible on your status. so this brings us onto the major question of this article…when is the best time to post your status…

  31. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More Infos here: eppc.org/publications/all-the-presidents-mandate-positions/ [...]…

  32. vital to check how it all looks…

    once it has hit the www. often when you transfer content from your computer to your website, you can get formatting issues or spacing issues, so make sure you always cast a quick eye over your latest offering once it is…

  33. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/all-the-presidents-mandate-positions/ [...]…