A Clash of Conscience

National Review Online | Published on

By James C. Capretta

Print Friendly


The decision last week by Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius to reject the appeals of scores of religious leaders and retain a very narrow “religious” exemption from Obamacare’s so-called contraception mandate has ignited an uproar among Catholic leaders, as well it should—because it’s hard to fathom a government dictate more offensive than this one.

Here’s how we got where we are: Obamacare includes within its massive delegation of power to the federal government the authority to define what constitutes “preventive services” that must be covered by all health-insurance plans sold and purchased in the United States, including plans sponsored by employers. Services defined by HHS as preventive for purposes of this provision are required under the new law to be covered by the insurer or employer with no charge to the insurance plan’s enrollees.

Last August, in the course of writing a rule that would determine preventive health services for women, HHS decided that free contraception and sterilization services are a must. As a practical matter, that means all health-insurance plans sold in the United States in the very near future will include full coverage of products that terminate pregnancies, since some products classified by the FDA as contraceptives—and thus covered under the HHS definition—also act as abortifacients. While it is true that many insurance plans cover such products today, that’s mainly been the choice of the insurers and employers sponsoring the plans. HHS has now made such coverage obligatory nationwide, thus forcing tens of millions of pro-life Americans to pay for “services” with their health-insurance premiums that they find morally objectionable. (Grandfathered plans are exempt from this and other Obamacare rules, but the number qualifying for grandfathered status is expected to decline precipitously in the next couple of years.)

Bad as all that is, it gets worse. Not only must Catholics who work for non-Catholic employers pay for such products with their premiums, HHS also wants religious employers to cover such products in their health plans. Knowing that Catholic leaders and others would strongly object to this requirement, HHS included in the regulation issued last August a narrow exemption from this requirement for employers that are basically houses of worship. Much larger religiously affiliated institutions, such as Catholic universities, hospitals, and charitable enterprises, do not fit within the HHS exemption.

Not surprisingly, Catholic leaders were more than alarmed by the promulgation of this rule and have spent the time since its publication imploring the Obama White House and HHS to reverse course and loosen the exemption definition so that the full array of Catholic institutions and social-service agencies could get out from under this onerous and pernicious requirement. Among the more prominent groups that have weighed in on this are Catholic Charities USA, the University of Notre Dame, and the network of Catholic hospitals that serve millions of U.S. patients every year.

This is not exactly a who’s-who list of the Catholic Right. If ever there were a group of Catholic institutions to which you would think that the Obama administration would want to be accommodating, this would be it.

And so, what was the administration’s reaction to the pleadings of these friendly leaders? Basically, the back of the hand. Last Friday, Secretary Sebelius announced that religious organizations that do not fit within the previously stated exemption criteria will have only one additional year to comply with the regulation’s requirements.

On one level, this was a truly stunning decision. Everything the administration has been doing in recent months has been political, with reelection plainly the primary motivation. But on the surface, this looks to be anything but a smart political move. With one decision, the Obama White House has made it all but impossible to sustain a serious Catholic argument in its favor. The veneer of religious tolerance, so carefully cultivated by Obama in the 2008 campaign, has now been completely stripped away.

On another level, however, there’s nothing at all surprising about what has transpired. Indeed, with Obamacare, it was inevitable—only a matter of time.

The central purpose of Obamacare—and the reason it was and is so strenuously opposed by so many Americans—is to transfer all of the critical decisions about how American health care operates to the federal government. Despite what the president contends, it is a federal takeover. The federal bureaucracy is now in the driver’s seat.

And, with the federal government now calling all of the shots, it is a foregone conclusion that a decidedly secularist and utilitarian point of view will be pervasive in everything that is done. It is simply beyond the capacity of the modern federal government to even consider arguments questioning the wisdom of governmental policies promoting free and abundant contraception. Indeed, it is an article of faith in the modern bureaucratic context that pushing such “prevention” measures onto the American public is one more step on the long march to a more just and humane society.

This is the environment in which we live. The hard truth is that the federal government cannot be trusted today with these kinds of decisions, and there’s no prospect of that changing anytime soon. That’s a big reason why Obamacare should never have been allowed to pass in the first place. Just the sight of Catholic leaders’ being forced to go begging before federal officials ought to be enough to convince most Americans that handing over so much power over such sensitive matters to the federal government was a terrible, terrible mistake.

If the Sebelius decision is allowed to stand, large Catholic institutions all over the country will be forced to stop offering health coverage to their workers, because continuing to do so will be incompatible with their mission. And when they drop that coverage, they will be forced by Obamacare to pay huge fines to the federal government ($2,000 per worker at the outset). For a Catholic institution with 5,000 employees, that’s $10 million that won’t go toward helping the poor, taking care of patients, or educating future leaders.

It is possible that the Obama administration will pull a political stunt later this year and broaden the exemption to curry favor with some gullible voters just before the election. But even if that were to happen, the real lesson of this episode should not be lost on anyone. Obamacare has handed over immense power to a federal government that is essentially hostile to religious sentiments. That’s a very dangerous state of affairs. Job number one must be to reverse course and replace Obamacare with a program more consistent with our Constitution and values.

James C. Capretta is a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. He was an associate director at the Office of Management and Budget from 2001 to 2004.

Trackbacks

  1. hacked games says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More Infos here: eppc.org/publications/a-clash-of-conscience/ [...]…

  2. Great…

    How does one make money from blogs? How does one go about it or start it?…

  3. ijeflowdo says:

    ijeflowdo…

    A Clash of Conscience – Ethics & Public Policy Center…

  4. Trackback says:

    I have some question…

    I’m a teenager and I heard that you can actually get paid for things like this. I’m experienced with computers and have good literature skills and I’m sure I can write successful blogs/articles… On a different (sort of) topic, would I be able to j…

  5. http://www.pimpblog.nl/jordans/

    A Clash of Conscience – Ethics & Public Policy Center…

  6. Like it…

    How does one find out how to become a blogger, or how much a blogger makes?…

  7. … [Trackback]…

    [...] There you will find 85928 more Infos: eppc.org/publications/a-clash-of-conscience/ [...]…

  8. Trackback says:

    Thank you…

    How does blogging/setting up a blog help a small to meduim size business grow?…

  9. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/a-clash-of-conscience/ [...]…

  10. Trackback says:

    Great…

    well my friend made a blog and he won’t show me what his blog is until he finishes everything with it. So i was wondering if there was a way to find someones blogger with their email address. If anyone could show me how. thatd be great thanks!….

  11. Trackback says:

    Great…

    so basically, i want to down; oad one of those programs that makes ur mouse pointer cool, but i don’t want it to screw up my computer… what’s a good one?….

  12. Trackback says:

    Thank you…

    Blogger/Blog*Spot feeds shows the most recent (recently updated as the default setting) 25 headlines or what others call as post titles. My question is how can I increase/decrease the number of those headlines because I think they’re too many…..

  13. Trackback says:

    Funny…

    The first piece is geotagging each blog post on some sort of map… The second piece is meshing those points on a map with other people. Essentially we’d like several members of our team to provide updates regularly and post their locations to the sam…

  14. Trackback says:

    Funny…

    How to stop importing blog posts on facebook? ‘Stop importing’ button is not found.?…

  15. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More Infos here: eppc.org/publications/a-clash-of-conscience/ [...]…

  16. Trackback says:

    Great…

    What Is The Best Way To Import MySpace Blogs To Facebook?…

  17. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Informations on that Topic: eppc.org/publications/a-clash-of-conscience/ [...]…

  18. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More here: eppc.org/publications/a-clash-of-conscience/ [...]…

  19. Trackback says:

    I like your blog…

    I want to start a fashion blog but have no idea where to start?…

  20. … [Trackback]…

    [...] There you will find 42071 more Infos: eppc.org/publications/a-clash-of-conscience/ [...]…

  21. … [Trackback]…

    [...] Find More Informations here: eppc.org/publications/a-clash-of-conscience/ [...]…

  22. Trackback says:

    I have some question…

    i want to put the blog comment approval on my myspace, but i cant figure out how to do it. some one please help…..

  23. Woman of Alien…

    Best get the job done you have finished, this page is really interesting with great data. Time is God’s method of holding anything from going on simultaneously….

  24. gcpbtkz says:

    gcpbtkz…

    A Clash of Conscience – Ethics & Public Policy Center…

  25. to excellent legal writing is to write…

    in plain english. documents should be written in a simple way so that the average person can understand the content. posting comments in forums and blogs is a great strategy to drive traffic to your blog or website. not only you…

  26. Trackback says:

    wow thats great…

    How can I copy-paste from Google Docs to WordPress and retain the boldfaced texts?…

  27. both for book-length manuscripts and even magazine…

    articles, already know that marketing starts from the beginning. most traditionally published non-fiction authors will come up with an idea for a book, and maybe write a chapter or two just as a writing sample, and then submit a proposal for…

  28. of professionalism. there are many skilled writers…

    or content companies online who can produce superior and quality content for all your website needs. most of them offer their services at very reasonable and affordable prices.optimal quality is guaranteed when you hire skilled web content writing prof…

  29. mlqhrwu says:

    mlqhrwu…

    A Clash of Conscience – Ethics & Public Policy Center…

  30. requires small capital. gone are the days…

    when you need to understand html or hire web designers to build you a site and pay a hefty price. there are websites where you can create your website for free. hiring web designers are also cheaper these days.there are lots…

  31. sqlsfuje says:

    sqlsfuje…

    A Clash of Conscience – Ethics & Public Policy Center…

  32. kwpgikpype says:

    kwpgikpype…

    A Clash of Conscience – Ethics & Public Policy Center…

  33. of the best blogging platforms that are…

    free to use for example blogger and wordpress. you can register with them free of cost and start your own blog. one of the biggest advantages of starting with free blogging platforms is they do not charge any money for your…

  34. he said: “if you don’t have time…

    to read, you don’t have the time (or the tools) to write. simple as that.”i totally agree! thanks for your time, frederic.thank you! have you ever seen an article on a blog that said it was written by a guest poster?…

  35. already been doing this, however if you…

    are continuing your life story, this will add insight into your writing and will begin your journey of conveying these thoughts and feelings to others. add this sentence each day for 7 consecutive days.four -on the fifteenth day, increase the length…

  36. in your belly. going to a spot…

    in your room where you could be inspired to write could be ideal. face towards the wall of your room where a nice picture frame of waterfalls is hung. this could be a good source of inspiration when you are writing…

  37. when paragraphs get too long, the content…

    becomes tough to follow, and you run the risk of losing your reader’s attention. a paragraph should be composed of a single idea. it is inclusive of an introductory sentence, topic sentences, and conclusions that easily transition into the next idea.t…

  38. there are websites where you can create…

    your website for free. hiring web designers are also cheaper these days.there are lots of ways to make money with a website the easiest one may be affiliate marketing. affiliate marketing is you promoting a product that belongs to someone else…

  39. aside. by the end of your trial…

    period, you will have a good idea of your ability to maintain those payments and a large down payment to put towards these purchases.bankruptcy is a tool to help you get back on track. it does not have to impact your…

  40. Imc9AElKLy says:

    The Absent Game…

    In between me and my husband we’ve owned additional MP3 gamers over the years than I can count, like Sansas, iRivers, iPods (basic & touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few several years I’ve settled down to one line of gamers….

  41. keep in mind is whether what your…

    putting up on your blog is helpful to your readers. if what you post isn’t the highest quality, consider revising it until it’s so high quality your readers won’t want to go anywhere else. if you are an aspiring author, if…

  42. most popular blog posts (anyone noticing the…

    theme of “lists?” ) share how you monetize your blog. list your best marketing ideas. or list ideas pertaining to your particular niche. ways to make your reader’s life a little better! write a list of 25 great blog ideas. ok,…

  43. that gets ranked in the top of…

    search engines? your probably tired of spending hours in front of your computer blogging daily and no one ever notices your posts. you have a message that you want people to hear but you just can’t get your article noticed or…

  44. JKmjPscMhD says:

    Thorn of Girl…

    Excellent information is usually observed on this web weblog….

  45. constantly. so, without any more delay, here…

    is our comment list of shame:hello, thanks for those informations that i found on your site. have a nice day. this is like one of the best tutorial i have ever came across on web..!!! guide is really very very good…

  46. wow thats great…

    Can my blogs be seen by others even if I do not buy a domain name?…

  47. the many article banks. they’ll provide you…

    with constructive criticism along the way.not everyone is good enough to be a professional writer, but who think they cannot be a successful writer could be, if they just believed in themselves.be the writer you were meant to behave you always…

  48. are the moderator will delete your account.my…

    recommendation is: find forums that are related with your blog (for example, forums related with dog training or louisiana golf players). browse the forum, see what kind of comments and topics people post. there are very bad forums around and you…

  49. issues. make sure to provide examples and…

    steps for them to follow. a great blog post will consist of all these things. in fact, i suggest that you spill the beans. give them your best information. if you can get these people to trust you, they will love…

  50. part of its shell. there have been…

    reports that some that weigh close to 700 pounds.thick-tailed gecko of this continent is also called the barking gecko. as the names imply, it has a wide, fat tail, and it makes a defensive noise that sounds like a bark. one…

  51. your blog can be placed in the…

    search engines very quickly because of it.i personally use a pinging service called “pingomatic”. you can google the name and visit their website. you simply enter your blog information in the 3 fields, and then click on the button that pings…

  52. cool site says:

    writing style while incorporating good ideas from…

    others and improving upon the not so good ones.blog writing is an art and you can develop it with continuous practice. watch out for what is making news in the blog world and you will have an interesting article every time…

  53. stuff ‘em in there!” don’t, seriously. search…

    engines run algorithms that find blogs that pack posts with keywords and punish them. i am not saying use few keywords. confusing? okay, here’s what you do: use the keyword around three times in your opening paragraph and maybe twice in…