Ethics and Public Policy Center
About EPPC Contact EPPC Support EPPC My EPPC
  Find:    
Home News & Updates Conferences & Events Programs Publications Fellows & Scholars

Home  >  Programs  > 
Bioethics and American Democracy
Home
Contact
News & Updates
Conferences
Publications
Books
Event Transcripts
Browse by:
- Author
- Title
- Type
- Date
Scholars & Staff
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Home  >  Publications  > 
II. Preserving Boundaries between Humans and Animals
Posted: Wednesday, February 1, 2006


BIOETHICS AGENDA


The Law:

  • A prohibition on the transfer, for any purpose, of any human embryo (produced ex vivo, by whatever means) into the body of any member of a non-human species.
     
  •  A prohibition on the production of a human-animal hybrid embryo by fertilization of human egg by animal sperm or of animal egg by human sperm.

Why We Need Legislative Action:

  • New areas of biotechnology and scientific research are rapidly blurring the boundary between human and non-human life—by introducing human cells into animals and animal cells into humans. We have pigs with human blood. We have mice with partially human brains and mice that produce human sperm. We have embryos created with rabbit eggs and human DNA.
     
  • A great deal of research involving both human and animal tissue is laudable and necessary for advancing science and medicine. But we must ensure that we do not violate human dignity by creating “hybrids” whose identity is in question or whose rights as a human person are undermined.
     
  • As man-animal research progresses, two inviolable boundaries need to be in place:
    1. No creation of a hybrid organism using animal eggs and human sperm or human eggs and animal sperm.
    2. No implantation of a human embryo into the body of a nonhuman animal. Human embryos belong only in human wombs.
  • We should not use animal wombs as human fetus farms. We should not grow human embryos in animal bodies, either for research or for growing human body parts.

What the Law Does:

  • It ensures that biotechnology can advance without violating human dignity.
     
  • It establishes two bright lines: no using IVF to create hybrid man-animal organisms and no using animal wombs to gestate or grow human beings.

What the Law Does Not Do:

  • It does not affect research on non-human animals.
     
  • It does not affect the current uses of xenotransplantation—such as using pig valves in human patients.
     
  • It does not affect the vast majority of experiments that mix human and animal tissue—e.g., introducing human neural stem cells into mice brains. It only affects those two types of man-animal experimentation specified in the law.




Related Links
Bioethics Agenda 2006
The New Atlantis Issue 23
The New Atlantis
A Journal of Technology and Society

The New Atlantis is an effort to clarify the nation's moral and political understanding of all areas of technology, with a special emphasis on bioethics. The quarterly journal is an attempt to make sense of the larger questions surrounding technology and human nature, and the practical questions of governing and regulating science— especially where the moral stakes are high and the political divides are deep.

In the latest issue:

       ... and much more!

For more information:

Read old articles in our archive.  
Click here to subscribe.  
Visit www.TheNewAtlantis.com today! 


The views expressed by EPPC scholars in their work are their individual views only and are not to be imputed to EPPC as an institution.
    Privacy Policy   © 1974 - 2012 Ethics and Public Policy Center
Comments on the website or technical problems? E-mail webmaster@eppc.org