Ethics and Public Policy Center
About EPPC Contact EPPC Support EPPC My EPPC
  Find:    
Home News & Updates Conferences & Events Programs Publications Fellows & Scholars

Home  >  Programs  > 
Bioethics and American Democracy
Home
Contact
News & Updates
Conferences
Publications
Books
Center Conversations
Event Transcripts
Browse by:
- Author
- Title
- Type
- Date
Scholars & Staff
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Home  >  Publications  > 
I. Embryo Creation for Research
Posted: Wednesday, February 1, 2006


BIOETHICS AGENDA


The Law:

  • A prohibition on the creation (by whatever means) of any human embryo solely for research, in which the embryo will be harmed or destroyed

Why We Need Legislative Action:

  • Scientists and researchers have begun routinely crossing a major moral boundary by creating, exploiting, and destroying human embryos as mere research tools or sources of human cells.
     
  • Many states—including California and New Jersey—have state laws that endorse, enable, and fund the practice of creating, exploiting, and destroying human embryos.
     
  • Whatever one’s view about using “spare” human embryos—embryos that are already frozen and left-over in fertility clinics, all first created solely for reproductive use—we can all agree that creating human embryos solely for research crosses a moral line.

What the Law Does:

  • It enacts into law the widespread moral consensus of the American public: most Americans believe we should never create, exploit, and destroy human life solely for research.
     
  • It protects women from being exploited as suppliers of human eggs, since creating embryos solely for research requires procuring human eggs solely for research.
     
  • It treats IVF embryos and cloned embryos with equal dignity. The Brownback cloning bill would prohibit the creation and destruction only of cloned human embryos for research. This law would prohibit the creation and destruction of any human embryo for research, no matter how it was created.

What the Law Does Not Do:

  • It does not affect, undermine, or limit research on existing embryonic stem cell lines.
     
  • It does not affect, prevent, or limit the derivation of new stem cell lines from human embryos created originally for reproduction but left-over in fertility clinics.
     
  • It does not change in any way the current federal policy on federal funding of human embryonic stem cell lines.
     
  • It does not change in any way current federal law or policy concerning abortion.
     
  • It does not affect diagnostic observations or tests to assess embryos created for possible use in reproduction.




Related Links
Bioethics Agenda 2006
The New Atlantis (Winter 2008)
The New Atlantis
A Journal of Technology and Society

The New Atlantis is an effort to clarify the nation's moral and political understanding of all areas of technology, with a special emphasis on bioethics. The quarterly journal is an attempt to make sense of the larger questions surrounding technology and human nature, and the practical questions of governing and regulating science -- especially where the moral stakes are high and the political divides are deep.

In the latest issue:

The Editors on John McCain and the Stem Cell Debate.
Yuval Levin on the past and future of the “party of science.”
O. Carter Snead on brain scans and the conflicted aspirations of neuroscience.
Matthew B. Crawford on the dangers of a mindless brain science.
Cheryl Miller on the lively and fractious community of “infertiles.”
Thomas W. Merrill reads Descartes’ Discourse on Method.
Jeremy Lott on suburbs, bomb shelters, and bottled water.
Christy Hall Robinson on celebrity patients as advocates.
James C. Capretta on why health care records are so low-tech.
Caitrin Nicol on predictions of robotic intimacy.
David Franz on the utopian origins of Dilbert's sorkspace.
George Mitchell on drugs in baseball.

       ... and much more!

For more information:

Read old articles in our archive.  
Click here to subscribe.  
Visit www.TheNewAtlantis.com today! 


 The views expressed by EPPC scholars in their work are their individual views only and are not to be imputed to EPPC as an institution.     
© 1974 - 2008 Ethics and Public Policy Center
      Comments on the website or technical problems? E-mail webmaster@eppc.org